Doors

How to Replace Exterior Door Trim: Boost Curb Appeal and Weather Protection

Wondering how to replace exterior door trim? If you’re spotting cracks, gaps, or signs of rot around your entryway, it’s probably time for an upgrade. Not only does fresh trim enhance your home’s curb appeal, it also plays a key role in sealing out moisture and maintaining energy efficiency. The good news? Replacing exterior door trim is a straightforward and satisfying DIY project that you can absolutely tackle.

At Builders Surplus, we’re here to help you take on home improvement projects with confidence, while keeping your budget in check.

Ready to get started? Reach out through our contact form or give us a call at 866-739-1636. We’re here to help you find everything you need, from trim boards to caulk.

Why Replace Exterior Door Trim?

Before diving into the “how,” it’s worth knowing the “why.” Here are some key reasons to replace worn or damaged trim:

• Curb Appeal: Fresh trim instantly sharpens your home’s look. 
• Energy Efficiency: Properly sealed trim helps block drafts and moisture. 
• Pest Protection: Old trim can harbor insects or provide entry points for pests to enter your home. 
• Water Damage Prevention: Cracked trim can lead to water infiltration and costly repairs. 

What You’ll Need to Get The Job Done

To replace your exterior door trim, gather the following tools and materials:

Helpful Tools:

• Pry bar 
• Hammer 
• Circular saw or miter saw 
• Caulk gun 
• Utility knife 
• Tape measure 
• Level 
• Nail gun or finishing nails 

Materials:

There are lots of beautiful ways to trim your doors and give the outside of your home a facelift.

• New exterior trim boards (PVC, wood, or composite) 
• Exterior-grade caulk 
• Paint or stain (if using wood) 
• Flashing tape (optional) 
• Finishing nails or trim screws 

Step-by-Step: How to Replace Exterior Door Trim

Here’s your step-by-step guide for installing exterior door trim for a quick upgrade! 

Step 1: Remove the Old Trim

Start by scoring the caulk line between the door frame and the old trim using a utility knife. Then, use a pry bar to gently remove the existing trim. Work carefully to avoid damaging the siding or door frame.

Pro Tip: If you’re reusing the same trim profile, label and keep one piece to use as a cutting guide for your new boards.

Step 2: Measure and Cut New Trim

Measure the vertical sides (called “legs”) and the horizontal top piece (called the “head casing”). Use a miter saw for clean, accurate cuts.

If your trim is simple square stock, 90-degree cuts will do. For more decorative profiles, a mitered 45-degree joint at the corners can give a finished look.

Step 3: Dry Fit the Trim

Place each piece of trim against the door to ensure a proper fit. Adjust as needed before securing them permanently in place. This step helps catch any measurement or angle errors before installation.

Step 4: Attach the Trim

Use a nail gun or hammer and finishing nails to attach the trim to the door frame or house sheathing. Be sure to nail into studs or solid framing when possible for a secure hold.

If you’re using composite or PVC trim, refer to the manufacturer’s instructions for fastening and spacing. Some require special screws or adhesives.

Step 5: Seal the Gaps

Once the trim is secured, apply a high-quality exterior-grade caulk around all edges where the trim meets the siding and door frame. This helps prevent water and air infiltration.

Smooth the caulk with your finger or a caulking tool for a clean finish.

Step 6: Paint or Stain (if Needed)

If you’re using wood trim, now’s the time to paint or stain it. Be sure to use an exterior-grade product that can withstand the elements. PVC or prefinished composite trim typically doesn’t require painting, but can be painted if you want to match your home’s color scheme.

Choosing the Right Trim for New England Weather

Living in Rhode Island, Connecticut, or Massachusetts means dealing with all four seasons. Here are a few trim options we recommend for local DIYers:

• PVC Trim: Moisture-resistant and low maintenance, great for harsh winters and humid summers. 
• Composite Trim: A blend of wood and plastic for durability and natural appearance. 
• Wood Trim: Affordable and classic, but be sure to paint or seal it properly to prevent rot. 

Whatever your style or budget, Builders Surplus has the right trim boards in stock and ready for your next project.

Upgrade Your Home with Trim from Builders Surplus

When it’s time to replace exterior door trim, skip the big box stores and shop local. Builders Surplus offers a wide variety of trim options at prices you’ll love, along with expert advice from our friendly team.

Our stores in Rhode Island, Connecticut, and Massachusetts are stocked with top-quality millwork and tools to ensure your project’s success. Whether you’re matching existing casing or upgrading to a new profile, we’ve got you covered.

Stop by your nearest location or get in touch online to talk with one of our experts—or call 866-739-1636 today!

Photo by Curtis Adams