Outdoors

Discover the key vinyl siding pros and cons before deciding if it’s the right exterior upgrade for your home.

Thinking about new siding for your home? Vinyl siding is one of the most popular exterior cladding options in North America—and for good reason. It’s affordable, low-maintenance, and available in a wide range of colors and styles. But like any building material, it has its drawbacks. In this article, we’ll break down the vinyl siding pros and cons so you can decide whether it’s the best fit for your home’s style, budget, and climate.

Want expert advice or affordable siding options? Call 866-739-1636 or contact Builders Surplus to speak with a knowledgeable team member today.

What Is Vinyl Siding?

Vinyl siding is a type of plastic exterior cladding used for weatherproofing and decorating the outside of homes. Made primarily from polyvinyl chloride (PVC), it has been a go-to choice since the late 1950s due to its durability, affordability, and easy installation.

Available in styles like traditional lap, Dutch lap, vertical panels, board and batten, shakes, and scallops, vinyl siding allows homeowners to customize the look of their home while protecting it from the elements.

Vinyl Siding Pros

Let’s start with what makes vinyl siding such a popular choice among homeowners and builders.

1. Affordability

One of the biggest advantages of vinyl siding is its low cost. Compared to wood, fiber cement, or brick, vinyl is typically the most affordable option in terms of both materials and installation.

• Average installed cost: $3–$8 per square foot 
• Lower labor costs: Lightweight and easy to install 
• Minimal long-term maintenance costs 

If you’re looking to upgrade your home’s exterior on a budget, vinyl is hard to beat.

2. Low Maintenance

Vinyl siding is virtually maintenance-free. Unlike wood, it doesn’t require painting, staining, or sealing. A simple rinse with a garden hose or occasional cleaning with soap and water is often all it takes to keep it looking fresh.

• Resists rot, pests, and mold 
• No peeling, flaking, or chipping 
• Holds color well over time 

This makes it a great option for homeowners who want curb appeal without the upkeep.

3. Durability

Modern vinyl siding is engineered to stand up to a variety of environmental conditions, including:

• UV rays 
• Wind (some products rated for up to 110–150 mph) 
• Moisture and humidity 
• Cold and heat extremes 

It’s flexible enough to expand and contract with changing temperatures, which helps prevent cracking in colder climates.

4. Variety of Styles and Colors

Today’s vinyl siding offers more aesthetic variety than ever before. Homeowners can choose from:

• Dozens of colors 
• Multiple profiles (horizontal, vertical, shake, scallop) 
• Textures that mimic wood grain 
• Trim, soffits, and accessories to complete the look 

This design flexibility allows you to match your siding to almost any architectural style—from traditional to modern farmhouse.

5. Improved Energy Efficiency (with Insulated Options)

Insulated vinyl siding includes a layer of foam backing that helps reduce thermal bridging. While it’s not a replacement for full insulation, it can provide a modest boost in energy efficiency.

• Helps reduce heat loss in winter 
• Adds a slight noise-reduction benefit 
• May contribute to improved indoor comfort 

Vinyl Siding Cons

While vinyl siding has many advantages, it’s important to consider its limitations before committing to an exterior remodel.

1. May Crack in Extreme Cold

Vinyl becomes more brittle in cold weather. In extremely low temperatures, impacts from hail, tree branches, or even a stray baseball can cause it to crack or chip.

• Less impact-resistant than fiber cement or wood 
• Can crack during improper installation in winter months 

If you live in a region with harsh winters, this is a factor to keep in mind.

2. Can Warp or Melt in High Heat

Although vinyl is designed to withstand summer sun, it can sometimes warp or melt when exposed to excessive heat—especially when installed near reflective surfaces like energy-efficient windows.

• Avoid installing near outdoor grills or fire pits 
• Opt for lighter colors that absorb less heat in hot climates 

Proper ventilation and installation can help minimize this risk.

3. May Not Add as Much Value as Other Materials

While vinyl siding improves curb appeal and protects your home, it may not add as much resale value as more premium siding materials like fiber cement, brick, or real wood.

• Perceived as less “luxurious” in high-end neighborhoods 
• May affect resale appeal in certain markets 

That said, vinyl siding is often still a good return on investment thanks to its lower initial cost.

4. Limited Repair Options

If a section of your vinyl siding gets damaged, it usually has to be replaced entirely—matching older siding can sometimes be a challenge if the color has faded or the style is discontinued.

• Keep extra panels on hand after installation 
• Repairs may be visible if color variation exists 

Proper storage and installation help reduce long-term repair issues.

5. Not Environmentally Biodegradable

While vinyl can be recycled, it’s not biodegradable and may raise environmental concerns for some homeowners.

• Made from PVC plastic 
• Manufacturing process uses non-renewable resources 
• Less eco-friendly than natural materials like wood or fiber cement 

However, many manufacturers are now offering more sustainable production methods and recycling programs.

Is Vinyl Siding Right for You?

When weighing vinyl siding pros and cons, consider your home’s location, climate, budget, and desired appearance. Vinyl siding can be a fantastic solution for homeowners who want an affordable, attractive, and low-maintenance exterior—especially in moderate climates or areas where curb appeal and cost are top priorities.

If you’re looking for the most natural appearance, the highest durability, or top-tier resale value, you may want to compare vinyl to other siding options like fiber cement, composite, or engineered wood.

Upgrade Your Exterior with Help from Builders Surplus

Now that you know the vinyl siding pros and cons, you’re better prepared to choose a siding material that fits your home and lifestyle. Whether you’re remodeling your exterior, improving curb appeal, or replacing damaged panels, the right siding can make a lasting impact.

Need help choosing siding for your project? Call 866-739-1636 or contact Builders Surplus to explore high-quality, budget-friendly options and speak with our knowledgeable team.

Builders Surplus proudly serves homeowners and contractors throughout Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Connecticut, offering a wide selection of first-quality siding materials at unbeatable prices. From traditional vinyl to insulated options and trim accessories, you’ll find everything you need for your next exterior project.

Visit one of our local showrooms to get started with siding that works for your home and your wallet.

Photo by Curtis Adams